(( Fortunately good sir, I do not wear my emotions on my sleeve, nor do I get upset over someone who disagree's, with me. We as a society would not be where we are without controversy, as for using the tools built into the forums, are they not there to be used ? If they are merely there to be decorative then by all means I will undo my actions, however I responded to each post as I thought was appropriate. I look forward to your private message so I may correct my actions if needed in the appropriate place, not in a thread intended to discuss the enchantment of axes.
As far as weapons being balanced or not, no one will ever be completely happy, I do think however some people die often to axes due to a lack of enchanted armor, lack of skill in pvp, or lack of combat skill in McMMO.
As it stands, axes can cause a critical hit in 2 ways:
Vanilla Minecraft
Mcmmo mod
A minecraft critical hit maxes out at:
11 damage for Axes
12 damage for Swords
A mcmmo Critical hit maxes out at:
20 damage for
Axes
0 bonus given in mcmmo.
Swords do up to 7 damage
Axes have a lower base damage than swords
Axes take twice the durability hit from combat as they do from being used on wooden items.
Axes damage armor
However swords do have:
Counter attack which can redirect damage to the attacker
Parry which can dodge attacks
Sharp V adds up to 7.5 damage to an attack
By removing the crit chance from mcmmo ( config file I believe ) axes do less damage than they currently do.
Swords would crit for 19.5 damage
Axes would crit for 18.5
Until now, Axes have been given a crit bonus to compensate for the lack of enchantments. Now that enchantments can be applied to axes, why not remove mcmmo's crit chance from axes all together to help level the playing field ?
Rather than stating they are Overpowered, specify which part of combat with an Axe is overpowered and offer a constructive way to resolve the problem.
just my additional 2 cents ))
