Do you actually think people are paying $9 for a piece of god armor? Because they're not. They're doing it for the recognition and to support the server. Nobody in their right mind would pay $9 for a piece of god armor, nor would they pay for a piece of enchanted gold armor. They would pay $9 to support the server. The only difference is that one of these options ruins the economy and the other does not.

I'm essentially going to rewrite the same thing I wrote on my other thread concerning this matter, but I'll do it anyways in case something was unclear in that other post.

This is from the Shop Terms and Conditions page. (https://www.massivecraft.com/shop-terms)

To me this sounds exactly like what it says. MassiveCraft/Cayorion reserves the right to fully remove a product without any refunds at all. The Gift4Alls are products. Massive reserves the right, therefor, to fully remove Gift4Alls without any refunds at all. I don't really understand what about this doesn't state that the server cannot remove the gift4alls without refunding the players. And again, the most that people could care about the gift4alls are as a sentimental thing... not much more than one of the voting items with their name on it. Because, again, nobody in their right mind would pay $9 for a god armor piece. They donate for the recognition and to help the server, and the armor piece is a sentimental thankyou item, that happens to have a use as a god armor piece and is ruining the economy.

In that case just remove the entire damned feature suggestion section.

Then perhaps if we actually ever heard anything about features before they were implemented we could save a hell of a lot of time writing suggestion threads.

As is the time that we put into the posts then.

There are so many threads on this it's not even funny. Maybe check some of those posts that you deemed a waste of time and effort to respond to?

Erm... the middle like several threads have suggested? Lower the enchants, turn the items to gold, whatever... See further up in this post as to why it doesn't really matter if the enchants are lowered.

Personally, I'd suggest a tiered system like what supposed to eventually happen the last time all of the EULA business happened. If not, then allow for people to choose the amount they donate, perhaps?

Both sound fine to me. Dozens of other ideas similar to these have been suggested on other threads with purposes entirely dedicated to ideas like these.

If gift4all is truly the only thing keeping Massive afloat... Well then I don't know. Because gift4alls have had a very obvious drop in number as of late... Of course the economic effects of them are still around...